CoE logo
Venice Logo

Opinion of the Venice Commission on Romania – Call for loyal cooperation of the state institutions in the interest of the State

18/12/2012

Early July 2012, the Romanian Government and Parliament adopted a series of measures in quick succession, which led to the removal from office of the Advocate of the People, the Presidents of both Houses of Parliament, a limitation of the competences of the Constitutional Court, changes on the conditions for a referendum on the suspension of the President of the Republic and the suspension of the President itself.

On 6 July 2012, the Secretary General of the Council of Europe has asked the Venice Commission to provide an opinion on the compatibility with constitutional principles and the rule of law of actions taken by the Government and the Parliament of Romania in respect of other state institutions. On 9 July 2012, the Prime Minister of Romania, Mr Ponta, requested an opinion from the Venice Commission on the Emergency Ordinances on the jurisdiction of the Constitutional Court and on the organisation of referenda.

Given that these requests overlap, the Commission decided to prepare a single opinion covering both requests. The opinion was adopted by the 93d plenary session of the Venice Commission held on 14 December in Venice.

The Venice Commission is of the opinion that these measures, both individually and taken as a whole are problematic from the viewpoint of constitutionality and the rule of law.

The Commission is worried in particular about the extensive recourse to government emergency ordinances – both by previous and present majorities – which presents a risk for democracy and the rule of law in Romania.

In addition, the events and several statements made demonstrate a worrying lack of respect among representatives of State institutions for the status of other State institutions, including the Constitutional Court as the guarantor of the supremacy of the Constitution.

The Commission is of the opinion that the respect for a Constitution cannot be limited to the literal execution of its operational provisions. The very nature of a Constitution is that, in addition to guaranteeing human rights, it provides a framework for the state institutions, sets out their powers and their obligations. The purpose of these provisions is to enable a smooth functioning of the institutions based on their loyal co-operation. The Head of State, Parliament, Government, the Judiciary, all serve the common purpose of furthering the interests of the country as a whole, not the narrow interests of a single institution or the political party having nominated the office holder. Even if an institution is in a situation of power, when it is able to influence other state institutions, it has to do so with the interest of the State as a whole in mind, including, as a consequence, the interests of the other institutions and those of the parliamentary minority.

The Venice Commission is of the opinion that the Romanian state institutions should engage in loyal co-operation between themselves and it is pleased about the statements from both sides expressing their intention to respect their obligations.

The Commission warmly welcomes the fact that its interlocutors were of the opinion that constitutional and legislative reform is required to ensure that a similar situation can not arise again. The opinion refers to elements, which could become part of such reforms.
© Council of Europe 2007-2020